Susan McCreadie, MD: I Rest Easier NOT Vaccinating my Children


Image from YouTube [1].

UPDATE: Dr. McCreadie has contacted us and informed us that this article is back up on a new nonprofit website [2] she co-founded and leads. This nonprofit organization is “dedicated to helping children live happier, healthier lives through REAL food, REAL health and REAL parenting.” Updated article:

I’m not opposed to vaccinations, I’m opposed to MANDATORY vaccinations. [3]

by Susan McCreadie, MD

Since finishing my pediatric training, I have come to realize that you can find evidence to support your decision to vaccinate or not to vaccinate.

When I started my pediatric practice fresh out of residency, I was a primary care physician and offered vaccinations to those families who chose to vaccinate their children. I actually gave the children the vaccines myself (I’m so glad I no longer do that – I truly disliked that part of my job!).

I was also one of the parents who chose to vaccinate my child. I did educate myself about the pros and cons of vaccines, and felt I still needed to vaccinate Kaitlin (my oldest), but selectively vaccinate and on an alternative schedule (one vaccine per month).

After the 5th  vaccine, her eczema continued to worsen. I started to have the uncomfortable feeling of having to step outside the lines of what the standard medical community recommended, on behalf of the health of my child. I have always been a rule follower, so naturally stepping outside ‘the standard of care’ was very uncomfortable for me – especially as a physician going against ‘my tribe’.

But…I am a mother first and a pediatrician second. This I have never forgotten. I cannot parent in ways that make me uncomfortable, to make others comfortable. I made the connection that Kaitlin’s eczema would improve if I stopped stimulating her immune system with the vaccines.

In addition to supplementing her with cod liver oil and probiotics daily, I also stopped vaccinations. Her eczema resolved and has never returned. I chose as a mom and a pediatrician to stop vaccinating Kaitlin, and never to vaccinate Elle or Addison.

These are my decisions. Are there risks? Sure there are risks. There are risks with EVERYTHING. That’s life. All three girls had whooping cough – not fun. Could I have prevented those 2 months of relentless coughing with vaccines? Maybe, maybe not. The family that spread it to our family was fully vaccinated against pertussis.

I am often asked my opinions on vaccinations – do I recommend them or not? Every time I answer with the story above.

There are pros and cons to vaccinations. As my training in holistic medicine continues, I rest easier NOT vaccinating my children.

My concerns lie beyond the ingredients found in vaccines. My largest concern is HOW we are stimulating the immune system through subcutaneous and intramuscular injections of vaccines. Our bodies have built in barriers to defend ourselves from “invaders” protecting us from infection, which are bypassed with vaccine injections. Let’s look at some of these built in barriers.

There has been a lot of focus on the importance of the annual flu vaccine. I have never received a flu vaccine as a medical professional EVER! Again, for reasons stated above I am choosing NOT to vaccinate. The flu vaccine, of all the vaccines, is the least effective at preventing its intended disease. See To Vaccinate or Not to Vaccinate [4] (link no longer active) for the research and resources that supports this statement.

We have A LOT of decisions as parents to make on behalf of our children.  Please Make an Informed Vaccine Decision [5] (link no longer active). I understand how public policy has chosen vaccines for public health; but when it comes to individual health it falls short in many many ways, because REAL health is beyond the absence of disease.

I am not pro or anti-vaccine, I am pro INFORMED choice. Think again – Watch the movie The Greater Good [6] to hear a rational scientific discussion from leading experts. This documentary weaves together the stories of three families whose lives have been forever changed by vaccination. Hear the vaccine debate reframed beyond fear, hype and politics.

Editor’s Note:

This article was written several years ago, and removed from most places on the Internet where it was originally published.

Reprinted in accordance with the “Fair Use” provision of Title 17 U.S.C. § 107.

About Susan McCreadie, MD